terrible hard case phone either falls out always if face is outward or it is IMPOSSIBLE to remove from hard case if face is turned backwardl...Another competing brand is better designed and this doesn't happen. I asked Otter to redesign the outer new case and their response is nil.

I'm not sure what you mean about the phone falling out. I don't see how in the world that could happen - my phone was locked tight in there, and Anthony didn't have any problems like that. Are you talking about it falling out of your belt clip, or the phone actually falling out of the case? (the phone only goes in the case one way)

I have no idea what Serena is talking about. You only put the phone in one way. Always falling out? Are you serious? You are obviously not utilizing the case correctly. I could take a hammer to this thing or throw it against a brick wall and it would still be in the case. Learn to use the case before you bash its value.

I understand what Serena is saying. I think what she meant is that when it is in the clip and facing outward (iphone face exposed), it falls out of the clip more easily. It is definitely difficult to get out of the clip when facing inward...very protected, but hard to get out of the clip. In fact, I cannot get it out with one hand and need two to press on the clip holder and phone to push it out. Very easy to reclip though. Overall, the case is very heavy duty and protective, and I like how I can view video with the iphone propped up instead of having to hold it. I've had many cases and am always looking for the latest and greatest...this is definitely one of the better cases despite it's added bulk as compared to other slimmer cases. I love the added screen protection as well.

It's simple to get out with the screen facing the holder (facing your body) you have to press on the middle bottom of the case and pull upwards. It is a VERY well made case, I am yet to put my iphone in it (case arrived before I picked up iphone) it is a great case. Only thing I would suggest would be to remove the window that shows the Apple logo; given some like showing that off it's just another spot for a potential failure, but I could care less about it personally. An amazing case, at a further point a case this size but waterproof would be great. The technology is out there to have waterproof headphone adapters and the membrane that you can speak/hear through but water will not enter. I'm outdoors alot and I get a little edgy using my iphone around water or on kayak/canoe trips.

Yeah and Otterbox makes some cases like that. Not for the iPhone, but they do make watertight cases.

The otterbox for iphone 3G is great. Main thing is protection, esthetics are not that important
(a friend called the otterbox a chastitiy-belt for the iphone LOL ).
One tiny problem. The polycarbonate sheet clings partially to the glas-screen and it looks as if there's a liquid between the screen and the polycarbonate sheet. I tried it with
anti-static cleaners. It worked for a while and then again it started clinging. Any tips ?

Pontiac...to fix that bubble i suggest using the Power Support Anti-Glare Film set for the Iphone 3G, i have this in combination with the OtterBox Defender and it removes that watermark affect and makes it nice and smooth. Others say that you can use baby powder, super lightly on the screen in between and it removes the watermark, i haven't tried this myself, but some say it works well.
Here's a youtube video on how to do this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Im7vvblnzoY

One thing worth trying, I've seen on some phone cases that the protective film can be turned over if it's bubbling too much and the other side doesn't do it so badly. Not sure why, but worth a shot if that's applicable here.

I have had the otterbox case since it came out. It is a very sturdy and well designed case. Deffinitely worth the money. Only issue I continue to have is with the belt holster. The two clips that come up to hold the phone break easily. I am on the second belt holster, thanks to their lifetime warranty. Only thing I would suggest for this product would be the strengthening of the two clips that hold the phone into the holster. other than that, A+ case.

@ Tyler:
I'm pretty active too, and I use my 3G's GPS all the time when I'm kayaking, camping, hiking, etc. with OtterBox's 1900 Series PDA Case. It's waterproof, but it has some downsides. When you open up the top port to use the headphones its no longer waterproof, but I've been thinking of buying some waterproof earbuds and putting them through the port, then filling in the hole with hot glue or silicone caulking or something. Another complaint I have with it is that it's not all that waterproof... I wouldn't trust it past 5, maybe 10 feet (but its more than enough for rain and puddles). Also, its not really made for an iPhone, but I cut some leftover high-density foam from a rifle case to fill in the extra space and its fine (probably adds some shock protection too). The screen cover on it is pretty thick to protect it from impacts and such, but its still useable.
So yeah, if you want an outdoor case, go for that. Here's the link:
http://www.otterbox.com/handheld-pda-cases/1900-se...

Just got the case yesterday and its fantastic! I was feeling really weird about the phone and how breakable it was. The case is super sturdy and it doesn't impeed on any of the touchscreen or button features even the volume is easily accessible through the skin. It makes the phone weigh a bit more but definitely worth it considering dropping or kicking it (like i tend to do to my phones) won't have any effect. Hell I can throw it against a wall and it won't hurt the phone a bit.

I have no idea what serena is talking about but even the clip is sturdy and holds the phone well as far as the case itself it's going to take all my technical skills to even get it out of the case. I don't use it as a belt clip (i just put it on my car dash) so maybe thats the difference. To address the bubble issue. I honestly had no idea that liquid was there on purpose I saw the bubble, paniced and whiped it off. Hasn't had any effect on the touchscreen or the ability to use the phone. It has the same sensitivities even through the second screen. Without the liquid I notice no difference in usage of the touchscreen.

I know what serena is talking about even when the iphone case is placed into the BELT CLIP properly the clip is not secure enough to hold the case if pressure is put on it or if you brush against something it may pop out.

This Is The Best Clip And Case I Have Ever Owned. As A Firefighter/paramedic My Phone Takes A Beating. I Have Dropped This Phone Is The Case From Several Different Hights With No Issue. Also It Never Falls Out If The Screen Is Faced Inward And It Is Easy For Me To Take Out With One Hand Since Sometimes Thats All I Have When I Need To Make A Call To The Hospital. My Only Complaint Would Be The Bottom Of The Case That Covers The Charge Port. I Think It Needs To Be A Little Wider That Way It Is Compatable With All The Fm Transmitters And Car Chargers. But Otherwise This Is An Excellent Case. My Drunk Friend Threw My Phone Across The Bar And It Landed Face Down. Nothing Broke. I Would Say If U Are On The Fence Buy It And You Wont Be Disappointed.

With reference to the ease of getting the phone out of the clip...one hand it by pulling it outward (away from your body) about 1/2 inch then lifting straight up! Just reverse the movement to put it back in... Place the bottom end in first leaning out slightly then push it towards your body 'till it cliks into a locked position.
My ONLY issue is with the severe echo caused by the sound within the case if you initiate a call with the charging port flap/door closed!!! I have heard that the issue is being revised and a slightly different design is being worked on.

I too have that echo that the calling party experiences!!!! What causes it and how do you get rid of it??? does any one else have this experience??

The echo goes away if you open all the silicone flaps or take the screen protector out.. The case is really dust prof but the sound can't escape and then resonates back to the mic it's really the only down side I would like to see if they fix that and the screen protector material

According to Customer Service, they are working on a tempory and later a permanent solution. They said one will be forthcoming next week. Sateck. doesn't taking out the screen protector negate the dust protection or have you found another way to protect the front screen?

Yeah if you take out the screen protector you lose some of the dust protection but if your not outside alot or in dusty conditions just use a regular screen film to protect the screen and then it takes care of the watermark and the echo problem and still protects better then any other case I found

I can't get rid of this watermark/bubble look!!!
I took the anti-glare film off, but it's still there. How do youfix this?

Angel76; take your case apart and rub your finger all over the inside of the clear cover (assuming you have a little oil residue on your fingers), it will keep the clear cover from sticking down and creating bubbles in-between. You might still end up with it not being perfectly clear, takes a little work to not, but it seems to be working for me so far.

Has the fix come out that was discussed on April 10, 2009? If so, where do I go to find it. The echo is driving me nuts.... Thanks!

It's a very good case- I like it a lot. The only thing I have a problem with is I'm about to order my third silicone cover. The ringer switch cover has ripped so when open it dangles.

I just got the yellow case last week and love it. I am a hiker/caver and trust and use Otterbox cases alot so when I got my new Iphone 3G I just had to get the Otterbox case for it. I use it with the Power Support Anti Glare film and haven't had any watermarks. I love how the case fully covers and protects the entire phone including all the ports and buttons while still allowing use of them. They are also one of few cases that show off the Apple logo on the back. I'm proud of my Iphone and love to show it off and this helps me do that even more with the eye catching yellow and black circling the apple logo. The only problem I have found with the case is at times after being on a call, the little area covering the proximity sensor fogs up from being against my face and takes about a minute to clear up so the touch screen will come back on. I plan on getting into geocaching and other outdoor things and this case not only gives me confidence that it'll protect my phone if I drop it on a trail but also gives it that great outdoorsy look that alot of trail gps devices have.