Choosing the Right Netbook
|
Author:
Editor:
Sponsor:
Published:
|
Max Slowik
Brian
N/A
Jan. 6, 2009
|
|
|
|
|
|
Style Over Substance
These two are both in the netbook market with the same goal in mind: make a sturdier, more business-like netbook. While they've succeeded completely, neither the Lenovo IdeaPad S10 nor the Samsung NC10 really show off much innovation. Having designed excellent chassis to their heart's content, both have only that to stand on. Still, the fact that they're more serious than the Acer and MSI netbooks is guaranteed to move product.
On paper, the two are exactly the same. In reality... Lenovo has a red model in addition to their black and white models. To be fair, the Lenovo weighs a little more, has a better display and speakers, and looks sharper, while the Samsung has Bluetooth and costs more.
Lenovo IdeaPad S10 at a Glance
Large keyboard and screen
LED backlight
Above average design
Fast 160GB HDD
Light at 2.8lbs
No Bluetooth
3-cell, 3-4hr battery
XP only, $400
Samsung NC10 at a Glance
Large keyboard and screen
Above average design
Fast 160GB HDD
Light at 2.8lbs
Bluetooth
6-cell, 6-7hr battery
Highest price among similar netbooks
XP only, $480
One Man's Trash
Dell's Inspiron Mini 9 is just another hop onto the bandwagon, and no number of artsy lid art is going to make it special on the inside (except maybe that it can be had with Ubuntu). The Mini 12, on the other hand, is an impressive piece of hardware worth saving up for, and for one and only one reason: it has a real screen. HP's 2133s had a significant advantage with that alone and for whatever reason, HP abandoned them. Thankfully, Dell picked up where they left off and went so far as to build it not only on an Atom platform, but a Silverthorn platform, that is to say, Atom the way it was meant to be. Instead of using the leftover GMA950 chips from four years ago, GMA 500 is designed to run on less power and is manufactured on a modern process.
Inspiron Mini 9 at a Glance
Linux Configurations:
LED backlit
Many colors and styles
Light at 2.4lbs
4-cell, 3-4hr battery only
SSD only
No Bluetooth
Kind of expensive for what you get
4GB SSD, 512MB RAM, $350
8GB SSD, 512MB RAM, $360
16GB SSD, 1GB RAM, $410
XP Configurations:
LED backlit
Many colors and styles
Light at 2.4lbs
4-cell, 3-4hr battery only
SSD only
No Bluetooth
Kind of expensive for what you get
Only available through Dell
8GB SSD, 512MB RAM, $400
16GB SSD, 1GB RAM, $450
Inspiron Mini 12 at a Glance
Large keyboard and screen
LED backlit
WXGA 1280x800 display
Silverthorn platform
Approximately the same size and shape as a MacBook Air
Slow 4,200RPM hard drive
Bluetooth optional for extra
Expensive
Only available through Dell
Vista Configurations:
1.33GHz (slower) processor, 40GB HDD, 1GB RAM, 3-cell battery (3-4hr), $500
Full-speed Atom processor, 60GB HDD, 1GB RAM, 6-cell battery (5-6hr), $600
1 - Posted by
Anthony
on December 14, 2008 - 1:37 am
I got my Dell Mini9 for $300 - XP, 8GB SSD, 512MB. I upgraded the RAM to 2GB and the new 16GB SSD will be here next week hopefully. Of course I'm just going to hack it and put OSX on it... =^)
Also, the Mini9 has has BTO Bluetooth option.
2 - Posted by
roberton
on December 14, 2008 - 2:25 pm
Funny you should mention nethack. I've got the original Eee (700?) and I do indeed play nethack on it a lot! This is partly on an installed copy, but more so now just using telnet to nethack.alt.org.
3 - Posted by
saxuntu
on December 14, 2008 - 5:05 pm
I don't know what the hell your talking about with the SSD being slower. I'm writing this on a Dell Mini 9. It loads Open Office faster than my computer with a standard HD, 3GHz processor, and the same amount of RAM. As for the keyboard its a 9 inch computer, what do expect. Complaining about netbooks being small is kind of missing the point.
4 - Posted by
paulb
on December 14, 2008 - 6:15 pm
Talking about missing the point (even when your intro touches on it) - netbooks' success are a classic case of the marketeers missing their own market ... the first generation were apparently thought of as low cost devices for students etc - hence their abysmal battery life. But the Atom generation brought with it some more serious battery specs ... particularly the Eee 901, creating for the first time a viable low cost alternative to high end sub notebooks. For those of us who have to do serious but simple work on the move (using Office-type tools rather than Photoshop etc) they were a godsend.
I'm with you on the preference for a decent hard disk rather than a cramped SSD. I had a 901 and liked it well enough but when my "proper" Toshiba failed I looked hard at the options and realised that a Samsung NC10 actually did pretty much everything I wanted from a mobile computer - a good keyboard, pleasant screen and more than enough poke to cope with office apps, even from Microsoft (I don't know what you're talking about there).
Netbooks aren't toys for geek modders - they are good, serious tools for work, and a sudden outburst of rational design and specification. In that sense the Samsung is not distinguished by particular features - it's just the best execution of the concept (for the moment).
5 - Posted by
Kurtis
on December 15, 2008 - 2:44 pm
I think I can speak for Max when I say that we know netbooks aren't just toys for geek modders. As writers, we very much realize the value of these little lunchbox 'puters, and I'm really glad to see that we finally have portable work computers with decent battery life that don't cost $3k.
Add Comment
To add a comment without being a member, you may omit the password field, but you must enter your name (or nickname) along with your comment. * Denotes required fields.
|
|